Discipline in a Blended Family
Question: We are both in our second marriage and the issue of who should discipline the children keeps coming up? How can we keep our stepchildren from becoming a source of division in our marriage?
One of the common unforeseen consequences of a second marriage is the difficulties that occur when each mate brings a child or children with them from their first marriage. It’s quite common for tensions and disagreements in a blended family to erupt over who should discipline whom, and how much discipline is called for.
It’s important for both mates to realize that a step parent will rarely be seen, at least at first (or even ever), in the same light as the children see their biological parent. That’s only natural since the children spent a significant portion of their life with both biological parents before their parents’ marriage ended. There is the heart of every child a God-given longing for the original parents to be together, even if the reality is both are now in new marriages.
This calls for showing tremendous empathy, understanding, and patience on the part of both of you. Children are in a grieving process, and one predictable element of that process is anger. Anger can take the form of talking back, refusing to follow directions, and even outright rejection of the new step parent.
It’s our conviction that the biological parent should be the primary disciplinarian in a blended family. Children are much more likely to respond to and receive correction from their parent of origin than the relatively new stranger in their life. That does not mean children should be allowed to act out or engage in defiant behavior toward their new step parent. Scripture calls for all children to show proper respect toward all adults, regardless of the family relationship. Therefore the biological parent should step in and stop blatant displays of disrespect when they occur.
Remember, as a step parent you are going to have to win the heart of your step children before you gain their respect. Therefore the more love, patience, kindness, gentleness, long-suffering, and self-control (see Galatians 5 for the entire list of attributes that will win your child’s heart) you display the sooner the day will arrive when they respond in genuine acceptance and love and obedience. There’s an old adage to raising children that applies here: rules without relationships produces rebellion.
Take the time to approach your stepchild as a caring adult and friend, rather than as the disciplinarian and taskmaster, and you’ll discover your rules with coupled with a loving relationship produces genuine heart response.
